Local builders digging basements in the 1950s reportedly found half-collapsed brick tunnels running parallel to the old trade roads. These tunnels, concentrated around Dobson's Tavern area (modern Main Street) and old commercial buildings on North Main and East Mountain Streets, were rumored to have been used for various purposes:
- Smuggling during Prohibition (hidden whiskey moving between shops)
- Possible connections to Underground Railroad routes before the Civil War
- Quick getaways for gamblers operating illegally
One property owner reportedly found a basement door that led to a blocked tunnel with old lantern hooks still bolted into the ceiling.